Book Review: Community: The Structure of Belonging by Peter Block
Peter Block’s book, "Community: The Structure of Belonging" is a compelling and human-centered exploration of how to build resilient, inclusive, and empowering communities. It’s not a technical manual, but rather a philosophical and practical guide to shifting the ways we think about engagement, leadership, and social transformation. Originally published in 2008, the book remains highly relevant today, especially in an age marked by increasing social fragmentation, civic disengagement, and a longing for meaningful connection.
Main Themes
1. Shifting the Narrative: From Problems to Possibility
One of
the foundational themes of the book is the importance of shifting our narrative
from one of deficiencies and problems to one of possibility. Block argues that
communities often fall into a trap of focusing on what’s broken — poverty,
crime, underdevelopment — and in doing so, they disempower themselves.
- Possibility Thinking invites
members to reimagine the future without being constrained by the
limitations of the present.
- This theme resonates with
appreciative inquiry — the idea that focusing on strengths rather than
weaknesses leads to more sustainable change.
2. The Structure of Belonging
The
core concept of the book lies in the title: belonging. For Block, a healthy
community is not defined by geography, demographics, or shared interests alone,
but by a felt sense of belonging.
- Belonging is cultivated through
intentional conversations and inclusive structures that invite people to
be co-creators rather than passive consumers.
- This “structure” isn’t
organizational hierarchy but a series of social agreements, norms, and
gathering practices that reinforce connection.
3. Leadership as Convening
Block
redefines leadership in the community context as the act of hosting and
convening conversations that matter. The traditional model of top-down
leadership is replaced by a more egalitarian and facilitative approach.
- Leadership is not about having
the answers, but about inviting others into dialogue.
- The “leader” becomes a social
architect, creating spaces where people feel safe to share, challenge, and
collaborate.
4. The Power of Questions
Much
of the book revolves around the idea that transformation comes not from
answers, but from asking the right questions. Block outlines a series of
conversations, each with its own set of provocative and open-ended questions.
These
include:
- The Invitation Conversation –
asking who is being invited and how.
- The Possibility Conversation –
shifting from prediction to imagination.
- The Ownership Conversation –
asking “What have I done to contribute to the current reality?”
- The Dissent Conversation –
making space for authentic expression, even if it’s uncomfortable.
- The Commitment Conversation –
fostering accountability and agency.
- The Gifts Conversation –
shifting from what’s missing to what’s present.
Each
of these conversations aims to shift the focus from passive complaint to active
engagement.
5. Community as Co-Creation
Block
sees community not as something to be managed or fixed, but as something to be
co-created. This requires a change in the way we see our roles — from client to
citizen, from consumer to contributor.
- The book emphasizes asset-based
community development (ABCD), where the focus is on what people can do and
what they have, rather than what they lack.
- Belonging grows through small
groups and local action, not grand strategic plans.
6. The Small Group as the Unit of Transformation
Block
repeatedly returns to the power of small group dialogue. Change happens when
people talk to each other, not when they’re lectured at. These groups, when
designed with intention, become laboratories for empathy, shared leadership,
and collective intelligence.
- Block critiques large-scale,
impersonal meetings and top-down initiatives in favor of decentralized and
participatory models.
- He provides a model for how to
design gatherings that foster trust, vulnerability, and ownership.
Writing Style and Tone
Peter Block writes in a deeply reflective and accessible style. His tone is thoughtful, sometimes philosophical, but never abstract for the sake of abstraction. He integrates stories, metaphors, and real-world examples to illustrate his ideas. While it may not appeal to readers seeking prescriptive, step-by-step instructions, its value lies in its invitational tone — mirroring the very spirit of the communities he advocates for.
- Strengths: The book’s clarity
of purpose, humane values, and insistence on dialogue make it a powerful
tool for anyone involved in community development, organizational culture,
or civic leadership.
- Limitations: Some readers may
find the lack of hard data or concrete case studies a weakness. It’s a
book that demands patience and introspection rather than quick fixes. The
idealism may also seem aspirational rather than readily actionable for
those working in deeply dysfunctional systems.
Conclusion
Community:
The Structure of Belonging is a transformative book that asks us to look inward
and outward — to see community not as a place or project, but as a practice of
radical hospitality, shared leadership, and collective responsibility. Peter
Block challenges conventional notions of leadership and engagement and offers
instead a hopeful, inclusive, and deeply ethical vision of how we might live
together with more meaning and purpose.
It’s essential reading for anyone — community organizers, nonprofit leaders, educators, municipal officials, or concerned citizens — who wants to build stronger, more connected, and more resilient communities.
Written by David L. Burton
MORE INFORMATION
Take the Engaged Neighbor pledge and become part of a movement! The pledge outlines five categories and 20 principles to guide you toward becoming an engaged neighbor. Sign the pledge at https://nomoregoodneighbors.com. Individuals who take the pledge do get special invitations to future events online and in person. Contact the blog author, David L. Burton via emal at dburton541@yahoo.com.
Comments
Post a Comment